Young men and women go off to die in wars started by old men and, sadly, women too. That's the way of the world.
My wishful solution has always been this: Revive the draft, make it truly universal, with no loopholes, no way to dodge it—not even for members of Congress. Oh, and make the draft age 55. Why am I bringing this up out of nowhere, you might ask. My answer: a Colman McCarthy column in the National Catholic Reporter. Reflecting on the new class of women in the 116th Congress, he expressed the hope that they'll remember the first woman ever elected to Congress, Jeanette Rankin. She so distrusted war that she voted against not only World War I, but World War II. In the resulting avalanche of hostility, she lost her seat twice. In his column, McCarthy lists several of his favorite Rankin quotes. At the top of the list: "You can no more win a war than you can win an earthquake." And just below it, this one: "If they are going to have war, they ought to take the old men and leave the young to propagate the race." That got me thinking again about making the draft age 55. This would solve a couple of problems. One is the Chicken Hawk problem: people who love war, who gladly push our nation into it, but don't want any part of fighting in it themselves. Two prime examples are George W. Bush and Dick Cheney. Despite my utter contempt for the current "president," he doesn't really belong in this category. Yes, he found a way not to be in the military. Hence, one of his many nicknames: Cadet Bone Spurs. Yes, he actually said that avoiding sexually transmitted disease was his own personal Vietnam. But at least he wasn't an advocate for the Vietnam War. He was too busy amassing money and failing to pay workers what he owed them. The other problem is the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain that helps us make wise choices. Generally, it doesn't fully develop until 25. That means that far too many young men and women join the military long before their brains are fully capable of making life-altering decisions, like subjecting themselves to repeated deployments to the Forever War. Some may join because of patriotism. Some are seduced by two endlessly repeated phrases in our culture, "decorated veteran" and "war hero," that make war seem the path to glory, when it's really the road to gory. Set the draft age at 55, make it impossible to dodge, and the number of stupid wars would decline sharply. This sounds Pollyannaish, of course, but not nearly as insanely optimistic as the mistaken view that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan can actually be won. We've been hearing that lie repeatedly since 2001. So, thanks to Colman McCarthy and Jeanette Rankin for stating and restating this simple truth.
2 Comments
Just want to say that having read other things by Bob Keeler, I respect his thinking and commenting on the subject he wrote about. I hope he does a lot more of that.
Reply
12/5/2019 10:06:39 am
Ok, I don't think most people are for war- although their may be a few insane people out there who are for WAR! Anyway, while I am not an advocate for war or raising the age for service. I think that unfortunately in this UNPERFECT world, we NEED the military and those that are willing and able to go in and serve should be allowed and called upon. It should remain a "volunteer" basis military- although once in things need to change and everyone should be respected for who they are and although are part of a group and need to be acting as such they should also be treated as the individuals they are! No lies from recruiters, no disrespect because one may have an education or come from another background, etc. LEAD BY EXAMPLE comes into play here. Maybe if our military leads by example and treats others as well the golden rule states. Then that will rub off on other militaries and their people, and so forth. And we will only use out "GUNS" for a just in case and never have to shoot! As insane and naive as that sounds- it is following the idea of our creator and his rule- no? And I do believe our motto is "One Nation Under God!" and no matter what relgion or what we call him- there is only one God everyone worships- granted he is called by several names but so are the many roads we use across the land!
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorFirst in my class in Officer Candidate School. Late to the conclusion that our attitude toward the military is idolatrous. Archives
February 2022
Categories |